O: Macy's Ad Plans Could Cost Newspaper Ad $$

Submitted by LynnS on Mon, 09/11/2006 - 11:58am.

The PBJ wrote to draw my attention to an article behind the paywall: As venerated longtime retailer Meier & Frank becomes Macy's, Macy's ad plan could hurt 'O':

If [new M&F owner] Federated's print advertising drops to 40 percent of its budget -- as expected -- The Oregonian could lose more than $2 million in annual revenue. Sources in Portland's advertising community say the change is already taking place.

To put that in perspective, the Akron Beacon Journal laid off 39 newsroom employees -- a nearly 25 percent reduction -- in order to make up for the loss of $2.3 million in ad revenue, according to a recent story in the Cleveland Plain Dealer.

The reason for the loss in revenue: The paper's biggest advertiser -- Kaufmann's -- had converted to Macy's. ...

Oregonian Publisher Fred Stickel, through an assistant, said the paper has been given no indication that Federated and its Macy's brand will advertise less than Meier & Frank. In fact, he remained confident the store would increase its local print advertising. The paper has long had an informal no-layoffs policy in its newsroom. ...

Analysts say it makes sense for Federated to spend more money on radio and television spots now that Macy's is a national brand.

"[Macy's] probably won't do as much [local advertising] as Meier & Frank did," said Kip Cassino, a media analyst and vice president at Va.-based Borrell Associates Inc. "They're a national retail company and they feel that their local advertising is buttressed by the national [radio and television] spots they buy." ...

Experts, such as Cassino, say newspapers no longer attract the young readers that retailers covet.

The article notes that despite declines in Oregonian print readership, OregonLive.com readership is up from 5% of Portland residents to 10% in the last year. (Attention Newhouse/Advance: Put the photos in the stories online and watch that percentage rise some more.)

The PBJ and the O are both owned by Newhouse/Advance.

Submitted by Anonymous Source (not verified) on Mon, 09/11/2006 - 2:36pm.

(Attention Newhouse/Advance: Put the photos in the stories online and watch that percentage rise some more.)

It's crystal clear that the folks at the Oregonian consider their photographers to be second-class citizens. There's simply no other explanation for the failure to put their photos in the paper. (Which doesn't make sense to me -- I think their photogs do great work.)

Submitted by walterburns on Tue, 09/12/2006 - 12:22pm.

There are plenty of other explanations. Mostly beginning and ending with the crappy system that is Advance Internet in New Jersey.

Submitted by Robert Hazlitt on Sat, 09/16/2006 - 6:10am.

It's not so much "the crappy system that is Advance Internet" at HQ in NJ -- if we're speaking merely of the mechanics of the online operation -- that inhibits the smooth and timely flow of text and art content from the newsroom to the Web, but the unwillingness within the Newhouse empire to pry the cold, dead fingers off the head of the "Live" operation. It annoys the section editors on up at The O to no end.

That said, Newhouse isn't known for thinking long-term when it comes to technological scenarios. Back when The O was finally forced to drag itself kicking and screaming into the Pagination Era, it came down two systems: $1M for Harris or $4M for CCI (used by USA Today), CCI being the Cadillac of pagination systems. Had Newhouse bit the bullet for CCI they would've ended up spending the same amount in the long run with far fewer headaches.

Submitted by LynnS on Tue, 09/12/2006 - 12:28pm.

The O photogs I've met are pretty happy with their lot and as far as I know are treated pretty much like everyone else around there. Their work not showing up online has nothing to do with respect and everything to do with an overly-cautious parent company with a way funky online strategy, if you wanna call it a strategy.

-----
Lynn Siprelle * Fairy Blogmother

Submitted by tvprintradio on Mon, 09/11/2006 - 6:31pm.

their free-lance budget? There are lots and lots writing for A&E, and a few for Living.

Submitted by Anonymous Source (not verified) on Mon, 09/11/2006 - 9:17pm.

This is interesting, because (having moved here from the Bay Area, and please don't hold that against me) Macy's always covered the Chronicle and the Mercury News with tons of ads. Here in the Oregonian and the Columbian, the Meyer and Frank ads were so prevalent and so similar in style that I thought Macy's already *owned* M&F!

Submitted by Betsy on Tue, 09/12/2006 - 7:06am.

...a month or so before the official takeover - we used to have these big blocks of black background/white type; and all of a sudden, there was white space! color! easier to read type!

Interestingly enough, I had the same story a month ago over on MetBlogs, with the same analysis: O to shrink even further as a result of (even more) lost ad revenue, coupled with a reluctance by Federated to spend more money on print 'cause it doesn't skew young enough. (Of course, I didn't have local O advertising numbers, nor did I get the reaction quote from the local dinosaur.) AdAge had a piece in early August about this; I reference it in the link above.

Submitted by LynnS on Tue, 09/12/2006 - 8:07am.

I'm an avid reader of the blog; somehow it passed me by. Sorry!

-----
Lynn Siprelle * Fairy Blogmother

Submitted by Betsy on Tue, 09/12/2006 - 8:53pm.

Wasn't meant as a criticism; I figured you might have been off having a life and/or concentrating on a healthy recovery, is all!

Submitted by LynnS on Tue, 09/12/2006 - 10:57pm.

I didn't take it that way, I just hate to miss stuff!

-----
Lynn Siprelle * Fairy Blogmother

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may quote other posts using [quote] tags.
  • Voting controls can be added to this post.
  • Web and e-mail addresses are automatically converted into links.
More information about formatting options